There is lots of good discussion all over the forum. I’d love to respond in all of them but it’s not feasible; instead I listen and try to guide us towards a solution that is considered fair by the majority of people (accepting that no solution can be perfect). More on this in the coming days.
I don’t personally agree with everything in this thread but the fact that the discussion is happening with thoughtful replies (shout out to @Kanenz as well for the data analysis) is encouraging and healthy imo.